Essential sewing keeping me clothed and sane

Indies 1- Newcastle


For the past week or so I have immersed myself in sewing from independent pattern companies. You know that I adore Vogue – take it out of the envelope, cut a 14, nip and tuck at the waist and lengthen by 3″ – job’s a good’un. Wear. But I was singularly unimpressed with the new season’s patterns and searched elsewhere – a change is a good as a rest and all that. Added to which I might stretch my sewing skills and learn some new techniques.

The results have been mixed. I was reading The Sewing Lawyer’s candid review of Cake patterns recently and thought I’d add my tuppence worth here. The patterns I used are:

By Hand, London – Anna dress

Thread Theory Design – Newcastle cardigan

Centre for Pattern Design – Four Square dress

Too much for one post, so I’ll split them into three – bit of a personal  review and then the finished article. I’d like to point out now that this is my personal experience with these patterns and therefore may not tally with anyone else’s.

Let’s start with the Newcastle cardigan, a men’s fleece/jacket. This is a downloadable PDF, therefore, instant. There are no reviews on PR so I was on my own with this one. I don’t usually sew for men, the cardigan was intended for teenage son, who is now standing at 6’5″ and I was feeling just a wee bit guilty at not sewing anything for him, considering his cousins got so much. He’s not that bothered in reality, so this was really to assuage my guilt.


Now there are a lot of things that can go wrong with PDFs, not least the printing. The 3″ test square was actually 2 3/4″ on my sheets which adds up to a total of 1 1/2″ missing from the width. This, of course, was only noticed after the tiling and cutting out of the fabric!

Teenage son joined in and tiled the 33 A4s, most of which fitted fine, but one or two were way out and required mucking about with when cutting out the fabric. I didn’t trace off the pattern from the tiled sheets but cut directly through the Sellotape and pages. If you take one piece of advice from this, for all print at home PDFs – TRACE. Keep the tiled sheet as your master and trace the required size onto tissue, it’s so much easier to pin to fabric and to cut through. I dread to think what I’ve done to blunt my precious Kai scissors. Thread Theory do however, include a print shop version of the PDF that can be printed out in one at a suitable printers. 10/10 for this as you could take this single sheet and lay it directly onto your fabric – all the pieces on the fold are along one side and the straight of grain is the same for all pieces – considered and practical pattern piece positioning

So, fault lies mostly with me on this one on the printing out and you can probably guess by now that the end result was not a super success.


I used a polar fleece and made version 1 with the contrasting shoulder patches and small collar. the jacket is navy blue with burgundy patches; I also made the under collar in burgundy too. Teenage son wanted a zip, not buttons and wanted inside pockets. He loves secret pockets. There are no pockets in this jacket, which seems a bit lacking, considering most men don’t carry a handbag and rely on pockets for bits of string, empty sweetie wrappers, dead batteries, £20 in loose change and the like.

The instructions are good, with photos and chapter headings. But I did become at bit confused with the notches especially on the sleeves (front and back) – maybe I’m just used to Vogue’s markings. There’s nothing too complicated about this cardigan – no darts, no sew-and-pivot at the collar – my biggest problem was getting 5 layers of polar fleece through my machine! Joining the collar and the facing to the jacket with the shoulder patches requires all this to pass though the machine in one go and mine measured a staggering 2″ before being squashed down. There is a warning on the instructions that you should check if your sewing machine can handle this, but by that stage it’s all cut out and waiting to be sewn. This sandwich of jacket/collar/facing is a neat and quick method of attaching them all together but mine required A LOT of snipping and trimming to lie flat afterwards.

Now it could be down to the printing, or the tiling or my sewing, or the fabric choice, but the pieces didn’t quite fit together perfectly. There was a lot of stretching and easing and pulling involved to try and match the notches and get some sort of symmetry at the front points of the collar. Added to which I was inserting a zip and not making button holes. I made it up as I went along to add this zip and it is inserted deliberately off centre so that there is a flap inside the jacket to stop the wind blowing through the zip’s teeth.

End result: Bear in mind that his is being modelled by Doris, who has a bust – teenage son does not!


Too small for teenage son. Tight around the chest and I added a band with a button at the bottom to lengthen it too.

Bulky and thick at the join of collar and jacket, even after the severe clipping and trimming.

Too low at the neckline – more like ladies wear than a man’s jacket. Could be because of the zip instead of buttons but I thought the plackets are relatively short in comparison to the jacket fronts.

No pockets. I added a secret patch pocket on the inside between the side seam and the the facing, sewing the bottom of it into the hemline.


Secret inside pocket. 0hh just look at those finished seams!


New labels have arrived


Extra bottom band with button closing

On closer inspection, the pattern photo has wrinkles at the collar edges and the top of the plackets. I don’t know if this is a design feature but it looks like something isn’t quite fitting correctly.


Thread Theory Designs are unique in that they are making patterns for men and that is an area that is sorely lacking in the pattern world. There are great reviews of the Jebbidiah pants on PR – singing their praise in fact.  On Thread Theory’s  blog are photos of real people wearing real Newcastle cardigans, all made by loving partners or mothers and they look fine. Some have the too low neckline that I ended up with and some do look a little tight. I suppose no one is going to publish photos of crap versions though.

Kay the Sewing Lawyer reckons that independent designers design for their own body shape and if you aren’t the same then the designs won’t look good on you. I can relate to that as a lot of the indie women’s wear are for 20 something girls, not curvy middle aged women like me. And while I can admire their designs on the screen they won’t be gracing my body.

Thread Theory designs primarily for her husband (the model) and he is tall and lanky, whereas teenage son is tall but broad, however, she also made a Newcastle cardigan for her dad (who is not tall and lanky!). I feel bad about this not working out first time, but then on reflection, how many patterns do? I mean, if I was to take a Vogue, cut and sew, it wouldn’t fit me – I just know what alterations to do now after years of using their patterns. The same must be true with the indies. I don’t know why I ever thought a pattern straight from the box is an automatic fit. I supposed I assumed that the indies take more time, more testing and produce an artisan item rather than a mass produced-fit-all pattern.

I like to encourage and support independent designers – I think many of their designs are unique and fill a niche that the big 4 do not. My version of the Newcastle cardigan is good enough in that the sewing and execution is fine and I finished all the inside seams on the overlocker (whey hey!) – it just doesn’t fit the intended wearer. So I’m on the look out for a man who is 6’5″ with a 34″ chest: is that physically possible?


18 thoughts on “Indies 1- Newcastle

  1. Oh, what a shame: it’s a beautifully made garment (well done) and looks so cosy and tactile!

    And I look forward to your further explorations in indie designs.

    Coincidentally, I’ve just done some experimenting with sewing for a very small teen. I don’t think he’ll ever grow to 6’5″ but if you can wait for a few years……

  2. Thanks for the review – I have this pattern, and have even had it printed out at the print shop. Just need to sew it up now – maybe not in fleece! I am really looking forward to your next reviews too.

    • That’s what I should have done – getting it printed on one sheet. Anyway, I hate to find fault but loosen the pressure on your sewing foot for the collar attachment.

  3. That’s a sharp pattern, I wish it had fit- someone would be very proud of it. I need to try more indie patterns that are for adults- maybe my fitting disappointments will not be so great.

  4. Have you thought about just adding racing stripes up the side seams and under arm sleeves for more ease? They could be a feature and no one would know. With men, we all need to remember those 3 little words…measure measure and measure. I have sewed for men, all sizes and heights and ages and as you read my blogs…even ones with gun holsters and they are way easier than women if you get all their measurements on paper and compare them to the paper pattern and then adjust. Indie pattern people have no idea what we look like, and as you have discovered…most designers design for themselves so if you don’t look like them…or are their age and style…it is a waste of time. Looking at the pattern diagrams…they look like women’s jackets, deep V in front. You did fabulous sewing and probably the best close seam trimming in the world but a bad pattern is just that.

    • I thought that straight up and down (no curves) would be an easy fit – ha ha ha! I’ll remember the measure times three for the future and should have consulted you sooner.

  5. So sad that it didn’t fit. I have taken on board your comment about tracing off a printed pattern. I think I would probably take the file to the local print shop as I am useless with IT.

  6. Thank you for your review of that pattern Ruth. I do alot of sewing for the males in my family. It has not been an issue until now getting patterns as it was for young boys and middle aged men, but my boys are now growing up and they want a much more fashionable look. They can sew but do not have the inclination to draw up their own patterns.

    This is big hole in the pattern catalogs.

    I recently enrolled in Kenneth Kings jeanius class so that I could copy DS2’s favourite jeans (almost like jodpurs us older generation hate them!!) but with problems with satellite download have not been able to work through the class which was very disappointing. I might check out these pattern lines and see what else they have.

  7. The jacket looks wonderful and very professional. Thank you for the review.

  8. Pingback: Indies 2 – Anna | corecouture

  9. Pingback: Back to Vogue Interview | corecouture

  10. Ruth, that’s a great jacket!! Too bad it didn’t fit.

    The square not coming to 3″ makes me wonder – if the printer settings were not right.. Say, while printing patterns, I need to specify “actual size”, do not shrink or something like that.. Makes me wonder if the pattern in each page got shrunk a bit.. ??

  11. Pingback: 2013 Sewing Year in Review | corecouture

Let's talk.....

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s